To each his own combat optics
I have my preferences and I tend to be very traditional when it comes to rifle scopes. I want thin black lines and I don’t like it when a reticle obscures the target. Nothing would bother me more than to have a combat optic that covered a target 300yds out that was firing back at me. There are a lot of short sighted operators in the weekend warrior crowd that just don’t cut it when they show up at competition shoots. I see so many people that just lack the proper setup or basic knowledge to engage targets at 300yds +. Hold overs are real easy when you know what your ammo is doing and you can see your target.
I realize that having an illuminated high visibility reticle means fast target engagements in close quarters fighting, but so does knowing your opic. The Trijicon TA01NSN is my favorite, not just because of the backup iron sights, but because the reticle is a very traditional skinny line targeting system, I like it. Those lines are are setup for 62gr SCBT and are very good for giving you 400-600yd shots. Not all combat shooting is about precision, precision shooting can me slow shooting and that can mean taking on return fire because you aren’t pinning your target down.